Just weeks after ruling against sharing voter data with the federal government, South Carolina Judge Diane Goodstein’s peaceful life was shattered when her Edisto Beach home erupted in flames. The October 4 blaze left her husband, former state senator
Arnold Goodstein, and others hospitalized after a dramatic rescue through the surrounding marsh.
Neighbors and emergency crews worked together, using ropes and canoes to pull victims to safety. The State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) launched an investigation but has not yet determined the cause, though arson has not been ruled out. The timing has raised alarm, as sources revealed the judge had previously received death threats. Chief Justice John Kittredge confirmed that an apparent explosion preceded the fire and that added security measures are now in place.
The tragedy struck shortly after Diane’s high-profile court ruling blocking the transfer of sensitive voter data to federal authorities. Once celebrated as a respected legal figure and community leader, Judge Goodstein now faces both personal tragedy and a deepening mystery surrounding the fire that destroyed her home.
