In an era where federal interpretations of biological sex are rapidly evolving, Christian educational institutions face unprecedented challenges. The central question, “Can a religious school act like a religious school?” might once have seemed rhetorical. Yet, in today’s legal landscape, many faith-based schools find themselves compelled to defend their right to operate according to their religious beliefs.

The Legal Battle for Religious Freedom

On September 20, 2023, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral arguments in a lawsuit against Charlotte Catholic High School in North Carolina. The school is under fire for requiring its teachers to uphold Roman Catholic teachings on marriage. This case exemplifies the broader struggle for religious schools to maintain their faith-based practices amidst changing legal interpretations.

Religious freedom is fundamental to the operation of faith-based schools, enabling them to exercise their beliefs within their communities. However, recent policy shifts present new challenges to this freedom. These changes have profound implications for Christian educational institutions across all levels, including K-12 schools, colleges, and graduate programs. A particularly contentious issue is the expanded interpretation of federal non-discrimination policies to include gender identity.

Policy Changes Under the Biden Administration

Upon taking office in January 2021, President Joe Biden’s administration announced that it would interpret federal laws prohibiting sex discrimination to cover sexual orientation and gender identity. This reinterpretation included Title IX, a provision in federal statute that bans sex discrimination in federally funded educational programs. Title IX, historically known for promoting women’s sports, now under the Biden administration’s policy, allows biological males to compete in women’s sports, thereby complicating its original intent.

Most higher education institutions receive direct government grants or federal financial aid to students, making them subject to Title IX policies. However, Title IX includes a robust religious exemption, allowing Christian schools to uphold policies that align with their biblical views on gender and sexuality.

The Equality Act and Administrative Actions

While the Equality Act, a proposed bill that would add sexual orientation and gender identity to federal non-discrimination policies, has stalled in Congress, the Biden administration has pursued the same agenda through federal agencies. This approach bypasses the legislative process and implements policy changes incrementally.

Another significant shift is the interpretation of the Fair Housing Act (FHA), which affects college dormitories. In early 2021, the Biden administration decided that the FHA’s non-discrimination policy would include sexual orientation and gender identity, potentially requiring single-sex dorms to admit members of the opposite sex.

Legal Precedents and Their Implications

Recent court decisions have magnified the impact of these policy interpretations. In 2022, federal courts in Maryland and California ruled that tax-exempt status is equivalent to federal financial assistance. Consequently, schools with tax-exempt status, regardless of whether they receive direct federal funds, could be subject to the same compliance requirements as federally funded institutions. Although these decisions are currently limited in scope, their affirmation on appeal or replication in other jurisdictions could significantly impact non-profit educational institutions.

Navigating Gender-Related Policies: A Call for Clarity and Consistency

For Christian schools, clarity and consistency in religious identity are crucial for navigating new gender-related policies. Legal battles often hinge on whether a religious institution genuinely operates according to its stated beliefs. To defend their practices in court, schools must demonstrate confessional consistency across all policies and procedures, including employment and student conduct policies.

Beyond legal compliance, maintaining the integrity of their beliefs is vital for Christian witness. Schools should regularly review how their operations reflect their religious convictions. This proactive approach will better prepare them to stand firm if challenged in the future.

Practical Steps for Christian Schools

1. Review and Update Policies: Christian schools should regularly review and update their policies to ensure they align with their religious beliefs. This includes employment practices, student conduct codes, and operational procedures.
2. Legal Preparedness: Institutions should seek legal counsel to understand the implications of changing federal and state policies. Staying informed about legal developments can help schools navigate compliance issues and potential legal challenges.
3. Public Statements and Documentation: Clear public statements of faith and documented policies can provide a strong defense in legal disputes. Schools should ensure that their religious beliefs are explicitly stated and consistently applied.
4. Community Engagement: Engaging with the broader Christian community can provide support and solidarity. Sharing experiences and strategies with other faith-based institutions can strengthen the collective response to legal challenges.
5. Educate Staff and Students: Schools should educate their staff and students about the institution’s religious beliefs and the legal landscape. Understanding the reasons behind policies can foster a supportive community that upholds the school’s mission.

Conclusion

The landscape of Christian education is increasingly complex in a time of gender confusion and shifting legal interpretations. Faith-based schools must navigate these challenges with clarity, consistency, and a steadfast commitment to their religious beliefs. By proactively reviewing policies, seeking legal counsel, and engaging with their communities, Christian educational institutions can better prepare to defend their right to operate according to their faith.

ALSO READ

As the legal and cultural environment continues to evolve, the question of whether a religious school can act like a religious school remains pivotal. The answer will depend on the resolve of these institutions to maintain their identity and integrity in the face of external pressures. Ultimately, their witness to the world will be measured not only by their adherence to legal standards but also by their commitment to living out their faith in every aspect of their educational mission.